Third Time’s the Charm

The Bellrays' song "Third Time’s the Charm" delves into the theme of personal struggle and the quest for redemption. The lyrics reflect a journey of self-discovery and the realization of one's limitations. The protagonist initially believes in their strength and ability to influence others, but soon comes to terms with the fact that they are not as strong as they thought. This realization is a humbling experience, as they acknowledge their inability to make things right and the futility of their efforts.

The recurring phrase "Third time’s the charm" is a poignant metaphor for repeated attempts and failures. It suggests a cycle of trying and failing, with the hope that the next attempt will finally bring success. However, the protagonist admits to having "struck out big time," indicating a sense of defeat and resignation. The imagery of looking into a mirror and finding everything changed symbolizes a moment of introspection and the recognition of personal transformation, albeit not in the way they had hoped.

The song also touches on the theme of societal expectations and the pressure to keep moving forward despite setbacks. The lines about people saying to "find yourself a brand new day" highlight the common advice to start fresh, yet the protagonist struggles with the shame of past failures. The strong wind and silence from others further emphasize feelings of isolation and the challenge of finding something to believe in. Ultimately, "Third Time’s the Charm" captures the emotional turmoil of facing one's limitations and the difficulty of letting go of past dreams.