In a Lake

Mitski's song "In a Lake" delves into the themes of escape, reinvention, and the haunting nature of past experiences. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of the constraints and suffocating familiarity of small-town life, where one's past mistakes and first loves linger like an ever-present shadow. The metaphor of a single brand of soap symbolizes the inescapable scent of past relationships, suggesting that in such a close-knit environment, it's challenging to break free from the memories and associations that define one's identity.

The song contrasts this with the liberating potential of larger, more anonymous spaces. The imagery of backstroking in a lake represents a sense of freedom and endless possibility, where the sky is open and the past is left behind. This metaphor extends to the idea of starting over in a big city, where the anonymity and vibrancy offer a fresh start, free from the judgments and expectations of a small community. The city lights symbolize hope and new beginnings, providing a stark contrast to the "dark" of past experiences that are safely kept at bay.

Mitski's lyrics also touch on the emotional toll of past mistakes and the desire to avoid "memory lane." The song captures the struggle of trying to be good in a place where reputations are hard to shake, and the fear that once labeled as "bad," people may treat you worse. Ultimately, "In a Lake" is a poignant exploration of the desire for reinvention and the search for a place where one can truly start anew, free from the burdens of the past.