Why Would You Be Loved

Hozier's song 'Why Would You Be Loved' delves into the complexities and inherent contradictions of love and trust. The lyrics oscillate between the euphoria of holding love and the existential questioning of its worth when faced with its transient nature and potential for pain. The song begins with a reflection on the temporary nature of love, suggesting that while it is a cherished state, it is also something that is 'loaned' rather than owned, highlighting the fragility and fleetingness of emotional connections.

The chorus repeatedly questions the rationale behind seeking love ('Why would you be lovin'') and the desire to be loved in return ('Why would you be loved'), suggesting a skepticism about the value and authenticity of these emotional pursuits. This theme is further explored through the imagery of playing all on something as 'hollow as trust,' pointing to the vulnerability and risk involved in giving oneself fully to another person. The lyrics question whether the emotional investment in love is worth the potential heartache, especially when one might 'come short when the going gets rough.'

The song also touches on personal pain and the feeling of being overlooked ('What about me and my achin'?'). It reflects a broader existential and perhaps even social commentary on how individuals grapple with their own suffering while seeking meaningful connections. This introspective inquiry makes 'Why Would You Be Loved' a poignant exploration of love's complexities, challenging listeners to reflect on their own relationships and the human condition.