What's The Matter Here

In 'What's The Matter Here' by 10000 Maniacs, the lyrics paint a vivid and heart-wrenching picture of child abuse witnessed by a neighbor. The song's narrator is deeply troubled by the mistreatment of a young boy living nearby. The boy, who remains unnamed, is a familiar face in the neighborhood, often seen trying to escape his abusive father. The narrator's repeated question, 'Oh, what's the matter here?' underscores their frustration and helplessness in the face of the boy's suffering.

The song delves into the complexities of witnessing abuse and the moral dilemma of whether to intervene. The narrator is tired of the excuses made by the boy's parents and society at large, which often dismisses such behavior with the notion that 'he's their kid.' This sentiment reflects a broader societal issue where child abuse is often overlooked or ignored, leaving the victims without a voice. The narrator's internal conflict is palpable as they grapple with their disapproval of the abuse and their fear of speaking out.

The lyrics also highlight the emotional and physical scars inflicted on the boy. The threats and physical punishments described are brutal and dehumanizing, emphasizing the severity of the abuse. The narrator's plea for an explanation of the boy's 'awful crime' at such a young age is a poignant reminder of the innocence of children and the unjust nature of their suffering. The song ultimately serves as a powerful commentary on the need for societal intervention and the protection of vulnerable children, urging listeners to question their own roles in preventing and addressing abuse.